Lord Toby Young & the Online Safety Act: A Wake‑Up Call for Free Speech
In a rousing chat on Triggernometry, the sky‑scraper‑loving, podcast‑pushing Lord Toby Young turns the UK’s newest Online Safety Act into a lightning‑fast free‑speech debate.
What’s the Buzz?
The Online Safety Act is slated to give regulators a wide‑angle lens—think “big brother” meets “want‑to‑be‑protective.” It puts pressure on social platforms to police violent or illegal content, but the question is: where do we draw the fine line between safety and censorship?
Lord Toby’s Take
- “We’re riding a treadmill that’s always hitting the next stop,” says Young. “If we stop and breathe, we’ll hit a wall of either over‑censorship or, worse, a digital free‑fall.”
- He scoops up a metaphor: It’s like handing a toddler a fancy knife and then asking them to keep the kitchen safe. Agreed, safety is vital, but protecting the toddler’s freedom to doodle is equally important.”
- “We must establish real, transparent accountability,” he stresses, adding that tech giants know the policy details but not the user details—yet people still get silenced.
Why the Free‑Speech Union Matters
Toby’s Free Speech Union is on the front lines, demanding that the legislation uphold the spirit of free expression without turning an entire platform into a digital police station. He’s on a mission to turn the UK into a “public square” that doesn’t just silence dissent but invites debate.
Humour Level: 9/10
In the interview, Toby delivers witty jabs, like: “If Facebook doesn’t want us to write the post‑COVID bakery whether it’s real or fictional, then I’m getting a cake and a warning about fake recipes.” That kind of punch keeps the episode lively and relatable.
Takeaway
For Brits who believe in free speech, this conversation is a reminder that clarity, accountability, and transparency are the keys to keeping the internet a safe yet open playground. And with Lord Toby’s sharp wit, it’s as entertaining as it is enlightening.
Lord Toby Young’s Take on the UK’s “Safety” Laws
If you’re wondering why this UK law feels like a rubber stamp for Surveillance, Dobson, & the Ministry of Red Tape, dive into Lord Toby Young’s critique. He argues the Act started as a moral panic over kids stumbling onto auto‑harm sites and porn online, and it has ballooned into a fear‑filled fortress that gags not just the deviant but also the decent.
Why the Act is a “Safety”‑Queueing Disaster
- It was born in Theresa May’s era and expanded under Boris Johnson – meaning it was designed to scare rather than protect.
- Platforms now remove and age‑gate harmless content—think speech around grooming gangs or a 19th‑century blog—just to dodge a fine or jail time.
- There are no strong free‑speech safeguards in the text, so people feel like their honest opinions might land them in jail.
The Chilling Effect
Companies over‑censor because one misstep could mean a hefty fine or even criminal charges. As a result, a surprise twist is that you might now find old speeches behind a wax‑door of age restriction. All for the sake of “child protection.”
More than Just Net‑Censorship?
- We’re seeing 30+ arrests daily for “speech offenses,” a shocking number that suggests the law has a reach far beyond the internet.
- Last decade, the NHS recorded 250,000 non‑crime hate incidents – many driven by online posts that challenge government talking points on immigration or gender.
- The law threatens strict anonymity; encrypted apps like WhatsApp could see surveillance climb.
- There’s chatter about reviving blasphemy laws under anti‑Islamophobia tags, and workplace rules might soon outlaw office banter unless it’s “harassment”‑free.
How the Free Speech Union Is Rallying
The Free Speech Union has seen a big surge in members—primarily gender‑critical women now, but anyone who feels veiled. Since the Labour government took the reins, many people are on edge, fearing that the law could widen into a blueprint for authoritarian censorship.
Lively Call to Action
Remember, this isn’t just politics—this is about quieting voices that dare to be honest. If you feel the same, support the fight against mass censorship by:
- Donating through Locals
- Checking out our merch
- Staying informed on X by following @ModernityNews
In a world that’s increasingly uncomfortable with dissent, Lord Toby Young’s plea is a rallying cry: let’s keep the conversation alive and free from the clutches of over‑protective regimes.